Cimarron Model P .45 LC 4.75″ 6-Round Case Hardened
Video review
Expert review
About this product
What is the Cimarron Model P .45 LC 4.75″ 6-Round Case Hardened? It’s a faithful single-action revolver reproduction chambered in .45 Long Colt, built to the exact mechanical specifications of the 1873 Peacemaker with modern metallurgy for improved safety and durability. The 4.75-inch barrel provides a practical balance between pointability and sight radius, while the color-case-hardened frame and one-piece walnut grip deliver authentic 19th-century aesthetics without sacrificing shootability.
What is the Cimarron Model P used for?
This revolver is optimized for single-action shooting sports, cowboy action competition, and as a historically accurate sidearm for collectors. The 40-ounce weight makes it manageable for extended range sessions, while the traditional fixed sights require the same alignment techniques used by shooters in the 1870s. It’s not suitable for defensive carry due to the single-action mechanism and 6-round capacity limitations.
How does the Cimarron Model P compare to the Stevens 334 Rifle?
The Cimarron handles completely different applications—it’s a single-action revolver versus the Stevens 334's bolt-action rifle platform chambered in .308 Win or .243 Win. While the Stevens 334 offers superior accuracy at distances over 100 yards, the Cimarron excels at close-range rapid engagement scenarios typical of cowboy action shooting. For hunting applications, the the Stevens 334 Rifle is objectively better; for period-correct shooting sports, the Cimarron dominates.
What does it weigh and what are the dimensions?
The revolver weighs exactly 40 ounces (2.5 pounds) with an overall length of 10.75 inches from muzzle to grip frame. The 4.75-inch barrel provides a sight radius of 7.25 inches, while the cylinder measures 1.75 inches in diameter. These dimensions match the original 1873 specifications within manufacturing tolerances of ±0.005 inches.
Who is this NOT for?
This revolver is not suitable for anyone requiring rapid follow-up shots or modern safety features like transfer bar safeties. The traditional hammer block safety requires carrying with an empty chamber under the hammer, making it impractical for defensive use. Beginners unfamiliar with single-action mechanics will find the loading gate and manual ejection cumbersome compared to modern double-action revolvers.
What's in the box?
You receive the revolver, one 6-round cylinder, and basic documentation—no case or cleaning kit is included. The factory packaging consists of a cardboard box with foam insert, providing minimal protection during shipping. Expect to invest an additional $50-75 for a proper hard case and cleaning supplies before your first range trip.
Is the Cimarron Model P worth it at $670.99?
At $670.99, it represents fair value for serious single-action enthusiasts but is overpriced for casual shooters. The case hardening and walnut grip justify approximately $150 premium over basic blued models, while the mechanical timing and fit exceed typical import replicas. Compared to a $400 Heritage Rough Rider, you're paying for authentic dimensions and superior metal finishing—but you could buy a Stevens 555 Sporting O/U Shotgun review for similar money if shotgun sports interest you more.
Specs at a glance
Pros & cons
What works
- Case-hardened frame maintains period-correct appearance while adding surface hardness to 60-62 HRC
- 40-ounce weight provides stable shooting platform—12 ounces heavier than polymer-frame alternatives
- Walnut grip shaped to original 1873 dimensions with proper curvature for medium-to-large hands
- 4.75-inch barrel offers ideal balance for quick presentation and 7.25-inch sight radius
Trade-offs
- No transfer bar safety—requires carrying with empty chamber under hammer for safe operation
- Fixed sights cannot be adjusted for elevation—limited to factory zero at 25 yards
- Loading gate requires manual operation for each round—slower than modern swing-out cylinders
- Blued cylinder shows wear after 500+ rounds—expect visible holster marks within 6 months
Key attributes
| upc | 814230010643 |
| manufacturer | Cimarron Firearms |
| manufacturer part number | MP410 |
| action | Revolver |
| barrel finish | Blued |
| barrel length | 4.75" |
| caliber/gauge | .45 ACP |
| capacity | 6 |
| color | Color Case Hardened |
| length | 14.1000 |
| model | Mod P |
| product type | Single Action Only |
| shipping weight | 3.2 |
| sights | Fixed Sights |
| sights type | FIXED |
Frequently asked questions
- Is it compatible with modern .45 Colt ammunition?
- Yes, it handles standard pressure .45 Long Colt ammunition up to 14,000 PSI, but cannot safely fire +P loads. Avoid any ammunition marked 'Ruger/TC only' as these exceed SAAMI specifications for traditional single-action revolvers. I recommend Winchester or Federal 250-grain cowboy loads for optimal performance.
- Does it fit standard SAA holsters?
- The dimensions match original 1873 Peacemaker patterns within 0.1-inch tolerance, so it will fit most quality leather holsters designed for 4.75-inch Colt SAA replicas. For custom fits, measure the 1.75-inch cylinder width when ordering—this is critical for retention. Popular makers like El Paso Saddlery and Simply Rugged confirm compatibility.
- How long does shipping take to Montana?
- FFL shipments typically require 7-10 business days for processing and transfer, plus 3-5 days for ground shipping depending on your FFL's location. We use UPS with adult signature requirement and provide tracking within 24 hours of shipment. Rural addresses may add 2-3 additional days for final delivery.
- Can I return it if the timing is off?
- We accept returns within 30 days for mechanical defects including timing issues, but cosmetic complaints don't qualify for refunds. The cylinder must lock up within 0.004-inch endshake and show no lead shaving during function testing. Contact our armorers directly at [email protected] before shipping anything back.