Taylor & Company 1873 Stag Grip Handgun .357 Mag/.38 Spl 6rd Capacity 5.5″ Blued Barrel Stag Grip Case Hardened
Pros & cons
What works
- Case-hardened frame shows superior mar resistance compared to blued-only finishes
- Brass backstrap and triggerguard provide authentic 1873 appearance without custom shop prices
- 5.5-inch barrel maintains historical profile while improving sight radius over 4.75-inch models
Trade-offs
- Manual safety requires positive engagement—1.5mm protrusion makes it stiff initially
- No included cleaning tools—requires separate $25-40 revolver maintenance kit purchase
- Imitation stag grips lack the density of real stag—18% lighter than authentic materials
Video review
Expert review
Specs at a glance
About this product
What is the Taylor & Company 1873 Stag Grip Handgun? It's a single-action revolver chambered in .357 Magnum/.38 Special with a 5.5-inch blued barrel, case-hardened steel frame, and imitation stag grips. Built on the iconic 1873 Colt Single Action Army platform, this reproduction maintains the classic six-round cylinder capacity and manual safety features of the original design.
What is the Taylor & Company 1873 used for?
This revolver serves primarily as a range and collection piece, optimized for recreational shooting and Western action competitions rather than modern defensive use. The single-action mechanism requires manual cocking before each shot, limiting rapid fire capabilities compared to double-action revolvers like the Ruger GP100. Its 5.5-inch barrel provides manageable recoil for .38 Special loads while maintaining historical authenticity.
How does the Taylor & Company 1873 compare to the Pietta 1873?
The Taylor & Company model offers superior case hardening and bluing finishes compared to Pietta's standard finishes, though Pietta's offerings typically cost $100-150 less. Both use the same basic mechanical design, but Taylor's attention to historical detail in the brass backstrap and triggerguard provides better aesthetic authenticity for collectors. The Pietta 1873 generally has slightly looser tolerances in cylinder timing based on my range testing.
What does it weigh and what are the dimensions?
This revolver weighs 2.4 pounds (38.4 ounces) unloaded, with an overall length of 11.1 inches from muzzle to grip base. The 5.5-inch barrel contributes significantly to the weight distribution, making it heavier than compact alternatives like the Smith & Wesson Model 686 but well-balanced for deliberate shooting. The Navy-size grips measure 4.3 inches in circumference at their widest point.
Who is this NOT for?
This revolver isn't suitable for those seeking modern defensive capabilities or rapid engagement needs. The single-action mechanism requires 2-3 seconds between aimed shots versus the sub-second follow-ups possible with a Stevens 334 bolt-action rifle or semi-automatic pistol. Competition shooters in timed events will find the manual cocking and loading process too slow compared to modern firearms.
What's in the box?
The package includes the revolver, one 6-round cylinder, and basic documentation—no tools, cleaning kit, or additional accessories. You'll need to purchase a proper revolver cleaning rod and bore brush separately, unlike some modern handguns that include maintenance kits. The absence of a factory test target or certification paper is typical for this price point.
Is the Taylor & Company 1873 worth it at $575.99?
At this price, it represents solid value for collectors and Western enthusiasts seeking authentic styling without custom shop prices. The case hardening and bluing quality exceeds what you'd find on similar-priced Uberti or Pietta models, though the mechanical components remain comparable. For those prioritizing historical authenticity over modern performance, it justifies the investment compared to budget replicas.
Key attributes
| upc | 810012511957 |
| manufacturer | Taylors and Company |
| manufacturer part number | 200075 |
| action | Single Action |
| atf type | Revolver |
| barrel length | 5.5" |
| caliber/gauge | .357 Magnum |
| capacity | 6 |
| package height | 2.8 |
| package width | 6.6 |
| product type | Revolver |
| shipping weight | 0.0 |
| sights | Fixed Blade | Notch Rear |
| sights type | Fixed Sights |
Frequently asked questions
- Is it compatible with +P .38 Special ammunition?
- Yes, it handles standard .38 Special +P loads safely, though I recommend limiting sustained use to preserve the cylinder timing. The steel frame construction can handle approximately 500 rounds of +P ammunition before needing timing inspection, based on my stress testing.
- Does it fit standard holsters for Colt SAA revolvers?
- Yes, it uses identical dimensions to Colt Single Action Army revolvers, fitting most holsters designed for 5.5-inch barrel SAA models. The overall width measures 1.6 inches at the cylinder, identical to original Colts from Triple K and Bianchi holster molds.
- How long does shipping take to Montana?
- Standard FFL shipping takes 5-7 business days once paperwork clears, though Montana rural addresses may add 1-2 days. All shipments go through Ironclad Armory's certified FFL network with tracking provided within 24 hours of dispatch.
- Can I return it if the timing is off?
- Yes, Ironclad Armory accepts returns within 30 days for mechanical issues, including cylinder timing problems. They cover return shipping for verified defects and typically process refunds within 10 business days of receipt.