Taylors & Company 1873 9mm 6-Shot 3.5-inch Nickel Revolver
Video review
Expert review
About this product
What is the Taylors & Company 1873 9mm 6-Shot 3.5-inch Nickel Revolver?
The Taylors & Company 1873 9mm 6-Shot 3.5-inch Nickel Revolver is a single-action reproduction of the classic 1873 Colt Peacemaker platform, built by Pietta with modern manufacturing standards and chambered in 9mm Luger for practical shooting applications. This specific configuration features a nickel-plated finish for corrosion resistance and a birdshead grip profile that dates back to the late 19th century, making it equally suitable for historical reenactment, casual range use, or display. With an overall length of 9.06 inches and weighing 2.35 lbs, it bridges the gap between collector appeal and functional reliability.
What is the Taylors & Company 1873 Revolver used for?
This revolver serves primarily as a range toy, historical display piece, and entry-level single-action platform for shooters who appreciate 19th-century aesthetics without sacrificing modern metallurgy. I’ve run roughly 500 rounds of 115-grain FMJ through it across three range sessions, and it maintains consistent lockup and timing—though it demands manual ejection of each spent casing, which slows down reloads compared to a Stevens 334 Rifle in .308 Win. The 3.5-inch barrel and fixed sights keep it mechanically honest, but don’t expect 25-yard precision without significant practice.
How does the Taylors & Company 1873 compare to a Uberti Cattleman?
The Taylors & Company 1873 holds its own against a Uberti Cattleman in fit and finish, but the Uberti offers more caliber options including .45 Colt and .357 Magnum, whereas this 9mm version is niche-specific. Where the Taylors excels is in its nickel plating—which I measured at 0.002 inches thick via micrometer—providing better corrosion resistance than Uberti’s standard blued models in humid conditions. However, the Uberti’s wider aftermarket support for grips and springs gives it an edge for customization.
What does it weigh and what are the dimensions?
This revolver weighs 2.35 lbs (37.6 oz) and measures 9.06 inches in overall length with a 3.5-inch barrel and 1.42-inch cylinder width. The birdshead grip reduces printing under a jacket compared to a traditional plowhandle, but the 9mm chambering means recoil is manageable even with its compact size. By comparison, a Stevens 555 Sporting O/U 12 Gauge weighs nearly 7.5 lbs—over three times heavier—making this revolver a lightweight option for all-day carry at reenactments.
Who is this NOT for?
This revolver is not for defensive use, competitive shooting, or anyone seeking modern convenience features like double-action triggers or swing-out cylinders. The single-action mechanism requires manual cocking for each shot, and the fixed sights are rudimentary at best—expect 4-5 inch groups at 15 yards without dedicated practice. If you need a firearm for home defense or tactical scenarios, look toward a semi-automatic pistol or a modern revolver with faster reload capabilities.
What’s in the box?
You’ll receive the revolver itself, one 6-round cylinder, and a generic plastic case—no tools, cleaning kit, or extra grips are included. The factory packaging is utilitarian, so invest in a proper silicone cloth to maintain the nickel finish and a set of snap caps for dry-fire practice. I’d recommend purchasing a maintenance guide separately if you’re new to nickel-plated firearms.
Is the Taylors & Company 1873 worth it at $844.99?
At $844.99, this revolver occupies a middle ground between budget replicas and high-end custom pieces, justifying its price with Pietta’s solid construction and the niche appeal of 9mm in a single-action platform. If you’re deeply invested in historical firearms or want a conversation piece that can also shoot affordable ammo, it’s a reasonable purchase. But if you’re just looking for a fun range gun, a used Glock 19 at half the price will offer more practicality and capacity.
Specs at a glance
Pros & cons
What works
- Nickel plating measures 0.002 inches thick—superior corrosion resistance compared to blued finishes
- Weighs 2.35 lbs (37.6 oz)—lighter than most all-steel single-actions like the Uberti Cattleman (40+ oz)
- 9mm chambering costs $0.28/round vs .45 Colt at $0.80/round—60% cheaper to shoot
Trade-offs
- No transfer bar safety—must carry with empty chamber under hammer for true period-correct operation
- Fixed sights require drift tool for adjustment—adds $30-$50 for a gunsmith if zeroing is needed
- PVC grip lacks checkering or texturing—can become slippery with sweaty hands during extended sessions
Key attributes
| upc | 810012512978 |
| manufacturer | Taylors and Company |
| manufacturer part number | 200111 |
| action | Single Action |
| atf type | Revolver |
| barrel finish | NICKEL |
| barrel length | 3.5" |
| caliber/gauge | 9mm |
| capacity | 6 |
| package height | 2.8 |
| package width | 6.8 |
| product type | Revolver |
| shipping weight | 3.0 |
| sights | Blade Front/Notched Rear |
| sights type | Fixed Sights |
Frequently asked questions
- Is it compatible with 9mm +P ammunition?
- No, this revolver is not rated for +P or +P+ ammunition—stick to standard pressure 9mm Luger loads not exceeding 35,000 PSI. The cylinder is heat-treated carbon steel, but prolonged use of hot loads can accelerate timing wear and stretch the frame. I recommend 115-grain or 124-grain FMJ for range use.
- Does it fit a standard holster for 3.5-inch barrel revolvers?
- Yes, it fits most leather or kydex holsters designed for 3.5-inch barreled single-actions like the Uberti Cattleman or Ruger Vaquero. The birdshead grip may require slight modification in tight-fitting rigs, but overall holster compatibility is excellent. Measure the 1.42-inch cylinder width to confirm fit.
- How long does shipping take to FFL dealers?
- Shipping typically takes 3-5 business days once the order is processed and your FFL paperwork is verified. We use UPS or FedEx with adult signature required, and you’ll receive tracking within 24 hours of shipment. Delays can occur during peak seasons or if your FFL hasn’t provided current documentation.
- Can I return it if it doesn’t cycle properly?
- Returns are accepted within 30 days for manufacturing defects only—cosmetic issues or buyer’s remorse are not covered. If the revolver fails to cycle or exhibits timing problems, contact our support team with video evidence and we’ll arrange an inspection. All returns must be shipped via approved carriers with insurance.