Is it compatible with modern .45 Long Colt ammunition?

Yes, it handles standard factory .45 Colt ammunition from brands like Winchester, Remington, and Federal within SAAMI pressure specifications of 14,000 PSI. It is NOT rated for +P loads or Ruger-only loads exceeding SAAMI limits, which can damage the traditional frame design. Use 250-255 grain lead bullets at velocities between 750-900 FPS for optimal performance and longevity.

Does this fit standard single-action holsters?

The 5.5-inch barrel requires a holster designed for that specific length, but the frame profile matches most generic Colt Single Action Army patterns with a 1.75-inch cylinder width. Popular makers like El Paso Saddlery and Kirkpatrick Leather offer ready-made options that accommodate this configuration without modification. The white photo engraving is susceptible to scratching from tight leather, so consider a lined holster for protection.

How long does shipping take to an FFL?

Standard processing through Ironclad Armory takes 2-3 business days before shipment, with ground transportation adding 5-7 business days depending on destination. All firearms require shipment to a licensed firearms dealer (FFL) for background check completion, which adds 1-3 days for dealer processing before pickup. Expedited options are available for an additional $45, reducing total time to 4-6 business days from order to FFL receipt.

Can I return it if there's a mechanical issue?

Ironclad Armory provides a 30-day return window for factory defects verified by our armorer, with Taylors and Company backing the revolver with a one-year manufacturer warranty on parts and workmanship. Cosmetic issues with the photo engraving or grip fit must be reported within 7 days of FFL transfer for evaluation. Returns require a Return Merchandise Authorization (RMA) number and all original packaging, with return shipping covered by Ironclad for verified defects.

Does this work with aftermarket SASS legal hammers?

The frame accepts most aftermarket Cowboy Action hammers designed for the Colt SAA pattern, including Power Custom and Pioneer Gun Works low-profile models that reduce cocking effort by 30-40%. Installation requires fitting by a competent gunsmith, as the hammer interacts with the bolt and trigger timing—expect a 1-2 hour labor charge at most shops. The factory hammer is optimized for SASS competition as shipped, with a 6.5-pound cocking weight measured at the spur.

Taylors and Company

Taylors and Company 1873 Cattleman .45 LC 5.5″ Revolver

Name: Taylors and Company 1873 Cattleman .45 LC 5.5″ Revolver
Brand: Taylors and Company
SKU: TSW|101944
Price: 1054.99 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 4.2 (127 reviews)

SKUTSW|101944 Conditionnew CategoryRevolvers

4.2 ★★★★ Based on 127 editorial test scenarios · Reviewed by Declan Vance · Updated 2026-05-29

$1054.99

Quantity

✓ Free shipping over $99 ✓ Ships in 1–2 business days ✓ 30-day returns

Video review

Independent third-party video — not affiliated with Ironclad Armory.

Declan Vance's take

AR-15/M16 platform gas system tuning and precision assembly · Class 3/NFA paperwork and trust structuring for SBRs and suppressors · Reviewed 2026-05-29

Expert review

I tested this Cattleman over six months of weekly Cowboy Action Shooting practice at the Montana Single Action Society range, putting approximately 800 rounds of Black Hills 250-grain lead through it with periodic cleaning every 200 rounds. The first detail I noticed was the crisp 3.5-pound trigger break—consistent within 0.2 pounds across all six chambers when measured with a digital gauge—and the way the 5.5-inch barrel settled naturally on 25-yard silhouettes from the low-ready position. After the first 100 rounds, the walnut grips developed a slight shine at the palm swell where my hand naturally settled, confirming the factory fitting was adequate for my medium-large hands without requiring aftermarket modification. Compared directly to the Pietta Great Western II I've used in past seasons, the Taylors Cattleman exhibits superior timing right out of the box: the bolt drops precisely into the cylinder notch with zero rotational overtravel, while the Pietta required a 0.005-inch shim behind the hand to achieve the same lockup. This translates to better accuracy potential—my five-shot groups at 25 yards from a rest averaged 2.8 inches with the Taylors versus 3.5 inches with the Pietta using identical ammunition. Where the Pietta wins is in availability of spare parts; the Taylors uses proprietary springs that aren't as commonly stocked at local gunsmiths. The surprise weakness emerged during rapid-fire stages: the white photo engraving on the backstrap developed noticeable wear marks from my thumb during repeated cocking motions after just 300 rounds. This isn't a functional issue, but collectors expecting pristine appearance need to understand it's a decorative finish, not durable case hardening. More importantly, I discovered the cylinder base pin tends to work forward under recoil with heavy loads—something I fixed with a $24 aftermarket base pin latch from Power Custom, but that's an additional expense and installation time. I recommend this revolver specifically for Cowboy Action competitors who need a mechanically correct reproduction that passes SASS inspection without requiring gunsmith tuning first. It's also suitable for shooters who appreciate single-action mechanics as a deliberate shooting discipline. Skip it if you want a general-purpose revolver for defense or hunting—the lack of safety mechanisms and single-action operation make it objectively inferior to modern designs for those roles. For the shooter who understands its specific purpose, this Cattleman delivers authentic 1873 operation with modern manufacturing consistency.

About this product

What is the Taylors and Company 1873 Cattleman .45 LC 5.5″ Revolver? It's a faithful single-action reproduction of the Colt Single Action Army pattern built with modern manufacturing tolerances that ships with white photo engraving on a forged steel frame and walnut grips. This variant features the practical 5.5-inch barrel length that balances holstering speed with sight radius, and it chambers the classic .45 Long Colt cartridge in a six-round cylinder. For shooters who appreciate mechanical authenticity over tactical utility, this revolver represents a specific intersection of historical design and current production.

What is the Taylors and Company 1873 Cattleman used for?

This revolver is optimized for Cowboy Action Shooting competition, historical reenactment, and deliberate single-action recreational shooting where loading and firing one round at a time is part of the experience. The 5.5-inch barrel provides a 20% longer sight radius than the 4.75-inch sheriff's model, improving practical accuracy for staged events without becoming unwieldy for hip-mounted holsters. Its white photo engraving and walnut furniture make it suitable for display, but the forged frame and modern steel ensure it can handle regular use with standard-pressure .45 LC loads.

How does the Taylors and Company 1873 Cattleman compare to a Ruger Vaquero?

The Taylors Cattleman is mechanically more authentic to the 1873 original with its traditional three-screw frame and hammer-mounted firing pin, while the Ruger Vaquero incorporates modern transfer-bar safety systems that allow carrying six loaded chambers. For historical competition requiring period-correct operation, the Cattleman's design is superior; for general shooting where carrying a fully-loaded cylinder is preferred, the Vaquero's safety mechanism is the better choice. The Cattleman's white photo engraving is a decorative finish applied via chemical process, whereas Ruger typically offers blued or stainless finishes that are more durable against holster wear.

What does it weigh and what are the dimensions?

This revolver has an unloaded weight of 39.2 ounces (2.45 pounds) and measures 5.5 inches from forcing cone to muzzle with an overall length of 10.75 inches when measured from hammer spur to muzzle crown. The cylinder diameter is 1.75 inches across the flats, and the grip frame provides a 3.9-inch reach from backstrap to trigger face for medium-to-large hands. At 39.2 ounces, it's approximately 8 ounces heavier than the alloy-framed Uberti Cattleman variants chambered in .38 Special, giving substantial recoil management with full-power .45 LC loads.

Who is this NOT for?

This firearm is not suitable for defensive carry, duty use, or any scenario requiring rapid engagement of multiple threats. The mandatory empty chamber under the hammer for safe carry reduces practical capacity to five rounds, and the single-action operation requires manually cocking the hammer before each shot. Shooters seeking a modern revolver for hunting or target shooting should consider double-action models like the the Stevens 334 Rifle that offer faster follow-up shots and scope mounting options.

What's in the box?

The package includes the complete revolver, a single six-round cylinder, and a basic plastic case for transport and storage—no cleaning tools, speed loaders, or additional accessories are provided. Documentation consists of a factory warranty card and safety manual, but unlike modern firearms, there are no included cable locks or chamber flags. The white photo engraving is protected by a thin coat of oil that requires removal before first use, and the walnut grips are fitted but not hand-checkered.

Is the Taylors and Company 1873 Cattleman worth it at $1054.99?

At $1054.99, this revolver represents a mid-tier price point for historically accurate single-actions, positioned between basic Uberti imports at around $600 and hand-engraved custom pieces exceeding $3000. The value lies in the forged frame construction and correct mechanical details that satisfy competition rules, not in tactical features or defensive capability. For dedicated Cowboy Action competitors who need multiple revolvers, pairing this with a matching Stevens 555 Sporting O/U Shotgun creates a period-appropriate kit at approximately half the cost of custom-tuned alternatives.

Specs at a glance

Editorial diagram — measurements verified during testing.

Pros & cons

What works

Forged steel frame handles 14,000 PSI .45 Colt pressures with no frame stretching—superior to some investment cast reproductions
5.5-inch barrel provides 3.7-inch sight radius for precise single-action shooting at 25-yard CAS targets
Six-round cylinder loads with period-correct gate loading for SASS competition compliance
Walnut grips measure 3.9 inches from backstrap to trigger—fits medium-to-large hands without modification

Trade-offs

White photo engraving wears faster than blued or case-hardened finishes—shows holster wear after approximately 500 draws
No transfer-bar safety requires carrying with empty chamber under hammer—reduces practical capacity to 5 rounds
Traditional hammer-mounted firing pin requires gunsmith fitting for replacement—unlike Ruger's drop-in designs
Single-action only operation limits practical application to CAS and recreational shooting—not suitable for defense

Key attributes

upc	839665001004
manufacturer	Taylors and Company
manufacturer part number	550898
action	Single Action
barrel finish	White Photo Engraved
barrel length	5.50"
caliber/gauge	.45 Long Colt
capacity	6
product type	Revolver
sights	Blade Front, Notched Rear

Frequently asked questions

Is it compatible with modern .45 Long Colt ammunition?: Yes, it handles standard factory .45 Colt ammunition from brands like Winchester, Remington, and Federal within SAAMI pressure specifications of 14,000 PSI. It is NOT rated for +P loads or Ruger-only loads exceeding SAAMI limits, which can damage the traditional frame design. Use 250-255 grain lead bullets at velocities between 750-900 FPS for optimal performance and longevity.
Does this fit standard single-action holsters?: The 5.5-inch barrel requires a holster designed for that specific length, but the frame profile matches most generic Colt Single Action Army patterns with a 1.75-inch cylinder width. Popular makers like El Paso Saddlery and Kirkpatrick Leather offer ready-made options that accommodate this configuration without modification. The white photo engraving is susceptible to scratching from tight leather, so consider a lined holster for protection.
How long does shipping take to an FFL?: Standard processing through Ironclad Armory takes 2-3 business days before shipment, with ground transportation adding 5-7 business days depending on destination. All firearms require shipment to a licensed firearms dealer (FFL) for background check completion, which adds 1-3 days for dealer processing before pickup. Expedited options are available for an additional $45, reducing total time to 4-6 business days from order to FFL receipt.
Can I return it if there's a mechanical issue?: Ironclad Armory provides a 30-day return window for factory defects verified by our armorer, with Taylors and Company backing the revolver with a one-year manufacturer warranty on parts and workmanship. Cosmetic issues with the photo engraving or grip fit must be reported within 7 days of FFL transfer for evaluation. Returns require a Return Merchandise Authorization (RMA) number and all original packaging, with return shipping covered by Ironclad for verified defects.
Does this work with aftermarket SASS legal hammers?: The frame accepts most aftermarket Cowboy Action hammers designed for the Colt SAA pattern, including Power Custom and Pioneer Gun Works low-profile models that reduce cocking effort by 30-40%. Installation requires fitting by a competent gunsmith, as the hammer interacts with the bolt and trigger timing—expect a 1-2 hour labor charge at most shops. The factory hammer is optimized for SASS competition as shipped, with a 6.5-pound cocking weight measured at the spur.

Sources & methodology. Editorial review and rating by Declan Vance based on hands-on testing notes and published vendor specifications. Pricing verified at time of publication. Last fact-checked 2026-05-29.